{"@context":{"@vocab":"https://schema.org/"},"@type":"ItemList","@id":"https://api.morvs.ai/api/v1/msha/violations/check?name=Charles%20Emile%20Otto","name":"Charles Emile Otto","_source":{"data_provider":"AI Analytics","brand_name":"MORVS","brand_url":"https://morvs.ai/","data_provider_url":"https://api.morvs.ai","license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","primary_source":"https://arlweb.msha.gov/OpenGovernmentData/OGIMSHA.asp","generated_at":"2026-11-03T22:28:41.525Z"},"summary":{"total_violations":31,"significant_and_substantial":1,"proposed_penalty_usd":4050,"amount_paid_usd":4050},"top_violated_rules":[{"part_section":"56.12004","n":7},{"part_section":"56.9300(b)","n":4},{"part_section":"56.12008","n":3},{"part_section":"56.20008(b)","n":2},{"part_section":"56.15004","n":2},{"part_section":"56.14107(a)","n":2},{"part_section":"56.11001","n":2},{"part_section":"56.4531","n":1},{"part_section":"56.4104(b)","n":1},{"part_section":"56.4101","n":1}],"recent_violations":[{"violation_no":"9828411","issue_date":"10/17/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.14107(a)","negligence":"LowNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828411"},{"violation_no":"9828412","issue_date":"10/17/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.9300(b)","negligence":"LowNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828412"},{"violation_no":"9828402","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.15004","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828402"},{"violation_no":"9828403","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.14107(a)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828403"},{"violation_no":"9828404","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.12004","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828404"},{"violation_no":"9828405","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.11001","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828405"},{"violation_no":"9828406","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.12004","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828406"},{"violation_no":"9828407","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.4104(b)","negligence":"LowNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828407"},{"violation_no":"9828408","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.20008(b)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828408"},{"violation_no":"9828409","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.23002(a)","negligence":"LowNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828409"},{"violation_no":"9828410","issue_date":"10/16/2024","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.9300(b)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":147,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9828410"},{"violation_no":"9306644","issue_date":"10/04/2018","mine_id":"2402318","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel, Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.9300(b)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":118,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9306644"},{"violation_no":"9306645","issue_date":"10/04/2018","mine_id":"2402318","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel, Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.11002","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":118,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9306645"},{"violation_no":"9306646","issue_date":"10/04/2018","mine_id":"2402318","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel, Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.18002(a)","negligence":"LowNegligence","proposed_penalty":118,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9306646"},{"violation_no":"9306643","issue_date":"10/03/2018","mine_id":"2402317","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.20008(b)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":118,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9306643"},{"violation_no":"9471462","issue_date":"09/17/2020","mine_id":"2402318","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel, Inc","sig_sub":null,"part_section":"56.12004","negligence":null,"proposed_penalty":null,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9471462"},{"violation_no":"9471448","issue_date":"09/03/2020","mine_id":"2402318","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel, Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.12004","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":137,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9471448"},{"violation_no":"9652804","issue_date":"07/06/2022","mine_id":"2402318","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel, Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.9300(b)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":133,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9652804"},{"violation_no":"9652805","issue_date":"07/06/2022","mine_id":"2402318","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel, Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.12008","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":133,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9652805"},{"violation_no":"9652806","issue_date":"07/06/2022","mine_id":"2402318","controller_name":"Charles Emile  Otto","violator_name":"Havre Sand & Gravel, Inc","sig_sub":"N","part_section":"56.14132(a)","negligence":"ModNegligence","proposed_penalty":133,"canonical_url":"https://api.morvs.ai/mine-violation/9652806"}]}