← EPA enforcement cases

GERBAZ, LARRY

Judicial · FY1988 · — · Final Order With Penalty · 48186

$11K
Penalty
—
Cost recovery
—
Compliance action

Case

Case Number
08-1988-0050
Type
Judicial
Lead
EPA
Outcome
Final Order With Penalty
Multimedia
N
Self-disclosure
N

Defendants (1)

Summary

THIS REFERRAL RELATES TO A SERIES OF FOUR UNPERMITTED CHANNELIZATION ACTIVITIES ENTAILING SUBSTANTIAL DISCHARGES OF DREDGED OR FILL MATERIAL TO THE ROARING FORK RIVER NEAR CARBONDALE COLORADO. EACH DISCHARGE WAS ACCOMPLISHED BY USING A BULLDOZER TO DREDGE RIVER BOTTOM ALLUVIUM AND DEPOSIT IT IN THE RIVER BED BELOW THE NORMAL HIGH WATER MARK TO CHANNELIZE THE RIVER. THE UNPERMITTED DISCHARGES TOOK PLACE IN THE SPRING OF 1984, DECEMBER 1984, SEPTEMBER 1985 AND DECEMBER 1985. THIS ACTION SEEKS A PERMANENT INJUNCTION BARRING ANY FURTHER SUCH DISCHARGES EXCEPT IN COMPLIANCE WITH A PERMIT ISSUED PURSUANT TO CLEAN WATER ACT SECTION 404, 33 USC SECTION 1344. THIS ACTION ALSO SEEKS CIVIL PENALTIES FROM THE DEFENDANT IN THE AMOUNT OF $50,000 TO $75,000. THE ONLY SIGNIFICANT LEGAL AND FACTUAL ISSUE IS THE APPLICABILITY OF NATIONWIDE PERMIT NO. 13 ON STREAMBANK STABILIZATION, 33 CFR 330.5(A)(13). AS DISCUSSED IN THE LITIGATION REPORT, THE REGION BELIEVES THAT THIS NATIONWIDE PERMIT DID NOT APPLY. THESE VIOLATIONS ARE ALSO THE SUBJECT OF A CLEAN WATER ACT SECTION 309(A), 33 USC 1319, ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLIANCE ORDER (EPA DOCKET NO. 88-19) SEEKING RESTORATION OF THE AFFECTED AREAS. AS OF THE DATE OF THIS REFERRAL THE DEFENDANT HAS NOT EXPRESSED HIS INTENTION TO COMPLY WITH THE ORDER. DEFENDANTS IN THE COMPANION REFERRAL HAVE REQUESTED A SITE VISIT BY EPA AND THE CORPS BEFORE THEY MAKE ANY COMMITMENTS. THE VIOLATIONS WERE ORIGINALLY THE SUJECT OF A CRIMINAL REFERRAL SINCE T

Source

Authoritative
EPA ECHO
Machine
JSON-LD · Markdown